Is the BBC planning to buy Channel 4? In an unusual turn of events, the BBC and Channel 4 have found themselves in the spotlight not for what they’re doing, but for what they claim they’re not doing.
On Friday, The Guardian reported that the BBC might be thinking about joining forces with Channel 4 to create a ‘public service television powerhouse’.
However, both the BBC and Channel 4 have quickly stepped in to say it’s not true. The BBC has firmly stated they’re not discussing buying Channel 4 or even thinking about it.
Channel 4’s boss, Alex Mahon, went even further, calling the idea “nonsense” and insisting Channel 4 isn’t for sale.
But this all comes at a time when the BBC is facing some serious challenges, especially with its primary source of money – the TV Licence fee.
Recent reports show that more people than ever are avoiding paying this fee, which is causing big problems for the BBC’s bank balance – and major changes will have to take place.
BBC And Channel 4 Considering A Merger?
The denials came in response to an article published by The Guardian, which suggested that the BBC was contemplating a “radical future” that could include a merger with Channel 4.
According to the report, this potential merger was being considered as part of the BBC’s strategy for the next round of licence fee negotiations, which is set to begin in January.
The Guardian’s sources claimed that such a move could create a “public service television powerhouse”, combining two publicly controlled broadcasters and potentially adding £1 billion to the BBC’s balance sheet.
The article suggested that Channel 4’s profits could be used to subsidise other parts of the BBC, creating a more financially robust entity.
One of the ideas suggests that Channel 4 could operate as a semi-independent entity under BBC Studios, the corporation’s for-profit subsidiary.
This arrangement could be similar to how the BBC owns UKTV, the parent company of channels like U&Dave and Gold, as well as the “U” streaming service (formerly known as UKTV Play).
It’s worth noting that Channel 4 operates under a unique model. While it is publicly owned, it is entirely commercially funded and doesn’t receive any money from the TV Licence fee or the government.
Instead, it generates its revenue primarily through advertising. This model was designed to create a public service broadcaster that would be innovative and risk-taking, while remaining financially independent from direct government funding.
In 2022, the government thought of selling Channel 4 to private hands, but that idea was eventually scrapped.
The BBC & Channel 4: It Ain’t Happening
In response to The Guardian’s claims, a BBC spokesman stated unequivocally: “There are no ongoing discussions regarding the acquisition of Channel 4 and nor are we developing a proposal to do so.”
This denial was echoed by Alex Mahon, chief executive of Channel 4, who dismissed the rumours in even stronger terms:
“The BBC have categorically denied this nonsense, and hypothetical imaginings of ownership models will not distract us from delivering for our partners, stakeholders, audiences and the whole of the UK. Channel 4 is not for sale.”
Adding weight to these denials, a government source confirmed to The Telegraph that ministers are not currently considering any such move.
This tri-part rejection – from the BBC, Channel 4, and the government – would seem to put the matter to rest.
However, ideas that get discussed unofficially at some capacity, sometimes become official at a later date (or disappear altogether).
The BBC’s Current Challenges: A Licence Fee Under Pressure
The merger rumours come at a time when the BBC is facing significant challenges, particularly regarding its primary funding mechanism: the TV Licence fee.
According to the BBC’s latest annual report, released in July 2024, TV Licence fee evasion rates have soared to their highest level in nearly three decades.
The evasion rate for 2023/24 climbed to 11.30%, up from 10.58% in the previous year. This marks the second consecutive year that evasion has exceeded 10%, a level not seen since 1995.
This trend represents a significant financial blow to the BBC, with evasion accounting for approximately £466 million in lost income for the year.
Furthermore, in 2023/24, the number of households declaring they don’t need a licence at all, swelled to 3.3 million, up from 2.8 million the previous year – a half million increase.
Experts suggest that this trend is driven by a combination of factors, including the proliferation of streaming services, changing viewer preferences, and the cost of living crisis.
The BBC’s own analysis indicates that the primary cause is a reduction in customers’ consumption of BBC and other licensable content.
Will The TV Licence Fee Model Change?
At the heart of the BBC’s funding model lies the TV Licence fee, a mandatory annual charge for households watching or recording live TV broadcasts, or using BBC iPlayer.
Currently set at £169.50 per year, the fee has been a part of British broadcasting since 1946.
However, this model has come under increasing strain in recent years. A two-year freeze on the fee at £159, lasting until March 2024, put considerable financial pressure on the BBC.
The corporation now estimates that rising costs and below-inflation changes to the licence fee equate to a real-terms annual reduction in income of 30% each year, amounting to over £1 billion.
And then, the changing viewing landscape further complicates matters.
The proportion of households watching licensable content – known as the TV penetration rate – fell to 90.19% in 2023/24, down from 91.54% in the previous year, as more and more people switch to streaming and on-demand content.
Despite these challenges, the BBC remains a significant part of the UK’s media diet.
The corporation reports that around 85% of UK adults engage with BBC TV/iPlayer, radio, or online content on average each week.
However, the average time spent with BBC services has decreased to 15 hours and 32 minutes per week, down from 16 hours and 41 minutes in the previous year.
As the BBC grapples with these mounting challenges, the future of the TV Licence fee model looks increasingly uncertain.
Negotiations over the future of the licence fee are expected to begin in January 2025 and last two years, with a deal needing to be in place by the end of the current royal charter in 2027.
The recent change in government has provided some short-term certainty for the BBC. Prime Minister Keir Starmer has committed his government to supporting the BBC and its current funding model, at least until 2027.
However, this commitment also leaves the door open for potential changes after the current Royal Charter period ends.
The newly appointed Culture Secretary, Lisa Nandy, has previously expressed strong support for the BBC and free media.
She has proposed making the BBC more accountable to its funders – the public who pay the TV Licence fee – suggesting a model in which the BBC is “owned and directed by licence fee holders.”
Whether through internal reforms, new funding models (such as switching to a subscription model), or potential collaborations, it’s clear that the coming years will bring with them major changes to the broadcasting market in the UK.
For more TV news and updates, Subscribe to our free newsletter.
How many license fee payers are needed to cover Gary Lineker’s mind boggling salary?
Why won’t the BBC switch from license model to an advertising funded
one? It works perfectly well in Canada with Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, Canada’s public broadcaster.
I think if commercials were added to BBC it would result in the subsidised parts being reduced – BBC Wales and Welsh content, BBC Bitesize, BBC Alba etc.